Maybe you want to know your farmer and know where your milk comes from or maybe you are struggling with digestive issues, allergies or skin problems.

Whatever the reason, we would LOVE to provide you with our farm fresh milk.

 Enjoy Fresh Raw Milk Every Week!

Raw milk is fresh, unpasteurized, non-homogenized milk from healthy, grass-fed cows.

What is a Dairy Herd Share Program?

Indiana law prohibits the direct sale of unpasteurized milk to the consumer, the only legal way to obtain raw milk is to own the cow. Cow sharing is a system that provides access to fresh raw milk for people who cannot care for a cow themselves. Purchasing a share entitles you to a percentage of what the herd produces. Shareholders are legitimate owners of the herd.

How much milk do i receive from a share?

Owning 1 share gives you 1 gallon of milk every week.

Owning 1/2 share gives you 1/2 gallon of milk every week.

How do I purchase a Herd Share?

You can become an owner in the Fagan Family Farm herd of dairy cows by purchasing as many shares as your family wants. It’s a one time purchase of $50 to buy 1 share and a one time purchase of $25 to buy 1/2 a share. If at anytime you choose to no longer own a share(s), we buy back the share(s).

After buying one or more cow shares, we will send you an invoice the first of each month for our weekly boarding and service fee. This fee pays to feed, milk and take care of your cow. Remember, we are selling the services not the milk!


Where and When Do I Pick-up My Milk?

thumbnail_2017-02-16 16.21.17.jpg

We will bottle your milk in new plastic jugs for you to pick-up from the locations listed below. You have the option of picking up your milk once a week, once a month or every other week. You will need to schedule a time with the Fagan Family to pick up your milk.

Pick-up Locations:

Fagan Family Farm

1035 N Jacksonburg Rd, Cambridge City, IN

1 Share – $8 weekly service fee

½ Share - $4 weekly service fee

Indys Community Food Co-op

2 Johnson Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219 

1 Share - $8 weekly service fee

½ Share - $4 weekly service fee

*Pick-up in Indianapolis will be available every other Tuesday.



If you are interested in raw milk, fill out the form below and we will contact you.

We will send you more information, our herd share contract and bill of sale, answer all your questions, and we are happy to set up a time for you to come and visit our farm.


Name *
First and Last Name
Yes, put me on your mailing list. *
Which location are you interested in picking up your share of milk? *
Please feel free to post any questions you might have in this box?